Why do we get crushes? The psychology behind the butterflies
Why crushes happen, why they pick the people they do, and why they feel so intense: proximity, reward, uncertainty and more, explained with research.
On this page
- 1. You see them a lot
- 2. Your brain treats them as a reward
- 3. Not knowing makes it stronger
- 4. You fill in the gaps
- 5. They’ve shown you a little interest
- 6. You feel close to them
- 7. They’re a bit like you, or a bit of what you want
- Why crushes on unavailable people happen
- Crushes when you’re already in a relationship
- So what should you do with yours?
- Frequently asked questions
You didn’t choose it. One week they were just a person in your class or office. The next, they’re the person you check for when you walk into a room. Why does that happen? And why that person?
Crushes aren’t random, even when they feel it. Psychologists have studied attraction for decades, and the same few forces show up again and again.
1. You see them a lot
The most ordinary explanation is also one of the best supported: we tend to like the people we’re around.
In a classic 1950 study of student housing at MIT, researchers Leon Festinger, Stanley Schachter and Kurt Back found that simple physical closeness shaped who became friends. Residents who lived near each other, or near busy stairways, formed more friendships. Psychologists call this propinquity.
A related idea, the mere-exposure effect, is that repeated exposure to something tends to make us like it more. With people, this works when the contact is positive; repeated bad experiences don’t create liking.
That’s why so many crushes happen in classes, offices, hostels, gyms and friend groups. They’re not lazy choices. They’re how human attraction tends to work.
2. Your brain treats them as a reward
When you see your crush, something happens in your brain that feels a lot like wanting. In a 2005 study, researchers scanned the brains of 17 people who were newly and intensely in love while they looked at a photo of the person. The scans showed activity in reward and motivation regions, including the ventral tegmental area and the caudate.
One of the researchers, Arthur Aron, described romantic love as “a motivation or goal-oriented state that leads to various specific emotions”. The team also found that romantic love and sex drive involve different brain systems.
So a crush works more like a drive than a plain emotion, which is why it can feel so restless and hard to switch off.
3. Not knowing makes it stronger
You might expect that people are most attracted to those who clearly like them. Reciprocity does matter: in a 2011 study, women were more attracted to men who they were told liked them a lot than to men who liked them an average amount. But the twist was that they were most attracted to men whose feelings were unknown, and they thought about those men the most.
Uncertainty keeps your mind returning to someone. That’s one reason crushes on people you can’t quite read are so intense.
4. You fill in the gaps
With a crush, you usually know some things about the person and imagine the rest. Imagination is generous. The gaps get filled with your hopes, which is why crushes can feel bigger than the actual relationship you have with someone.
This also explains why getting to know a crush better changes things: either the real person is even better, or the fantasy quietly dissolves.
5. They’ve shown you a little interest
People tend to like those who like them. A kind word, a laugh at your joke, a look that lasted a moment longer: small signs of interest can spark a crush, especially if you didn’t expect them. Research on the “liking gap” suggests we often underestimate how much others like us, so a clear sign of warmth can land with real force.
6. You feel close to them
Closeness builds attraction. In a well-known 1997 experiment, pairs of strangers who took turns asking increasingly personal questions felt far closer afterwards than pairs who made small talk. Late-night conversations, shared secrets and supporting each other through hard times all create this kind of closeness, which is why crushes on friends are so common. In a 2021 study, 68% of people said their current or most recent relationship began as a friendship.
7. They’re a bit like you, or a bit of what you want
People often feel drawn to those who share their values, humour or interests. Others are drawn to someone who has a quality they admire or wish they had more of: confidence, calm, talent. A crush can tell you something about what you value.
Why crushes on unavailable people happen
Celebrity crushes, crushes on people in relationships, crushes on someone who lives far away. These can feel strange, but they make sense: an unavailable person is safe. You can enjoy the feeling without the risk of rejection or the work of a real relationship. Many people have crushes like this and never act on them, which is perfectly fine.
Crushes when you’re already in a relationship
If you’re in a happy relationship and still get crushes, you’re not alone, and it doesn’t necessarily mean anything is wrong. In a 2021 study, people in committed relationships reported crushes too, often more than single people, and most had no intention of acting on them. Feelings were mostly positive, like excitement, with some guilt. A later year-long study of people aged 22 to 35 in relationships found that for many, having a crush didn’t lower relationship satisfaction.
A crush is a feeling. What you do with it is a choice.
So what should you do with yours?
Understanding why crushes happen can take some of the mystery (and some of the panic) out of them. Once you understand yours, you have choices:
- Enjoy it and let it run its course.
- Get to know them and see whether the crush grows or fades.
- Find out if it’s mutual. On Coy, you add your crush by phone number or email. If they add you too, you both find out at the same moment. If they don’t, nothing happens and nobody ever knows. See how Coy works.
Frequently asked questions
Why do we get crushes on people?
Proximity, repeated positive contact, closeness, small signs of interest and uncertainty about how they feel all play a part. Brain research suggests early attraction activates reward and motivation systems.
Why do I get crushes so easily?
Some people are more open to attraction, spend more time around new people, or are especially responsive to signs of warmth. It’s normal and not a flaw.
Why do I have a crush on someone I barely know?
Limited knowledge leaves room for imagination, which tends to fill the gaps generously. Getting to know them will usually deepen or dissolve the crush.
Is it normal to have a crush when you’re in a relationship?
Yes. Research suggests crushes are common in committed relationships, and most people don’t act on them.
Why do crushes feel so intense?
Early romantic attraction works like a drive, activating the brain’s reward systems, and uncertainty about how the other person feels makes you think about them even more.
Sources
- Festinger, L., Schachter, S., & Back, K. (1950). Social pressures in informal groups. Propinquity and mere exposure. Overview
- Aron, A., Fisher, H. E., Mashek, D. J., Strong, G., Li, H., & Brown, L. L. (2005). Reward, motivation and emotion systems associated with early-stage intense romantic love. Journal of Neurophysiology. ScienceDaily summary
- Whitchurch, E. R., Wilson, T. D., & Gilbert, D. T. (2011). Uncertainty can increase romantic attraction. Psychological Science. APS summary
- Boothby, E. J., et al. (2018). The liking gap in conversations. Psychological Science. ScienceDaily summary
- Aron, A., et al. (1997). The experimental generation of interpersonal closeness. Greater Good summary
- Stinson, D. A., Cameron, J. J., & Hoplock, L. B. (2021). The friends-to-lovers pathway to romance. University of Victoria
- O’Sullivan, L. F., Belu, C. F., & Garcia, J. R. (2021). Crushes in committed relationships. Psychology Today summary; O’Sullivan, Belu & Tramonte. PsyPost summary