Facebook Secret Crush alternatives: ways to find out if it’s mutual

What Facebook Secret Crush was, why it never reached most people, and the alternatives that let you find out if a crush is mutual today.

By The Coy team5 minute read

On this page
  1. What was Facebook Secret Crush?
  2. Why many people never got to use it
  3. Is Secret Crush still available?
  4. Alternatives for finding out if a crush is mutual
  5. How they compare
  6. What to watch out for in “secret crush” apps
  7. Frequently asked questions

In 2019, Facebook announced a feature that sounded like a dream for anyone with a crush: pick people you like, and if they pick you too, you both find out. If they don’t, nobody is told anything.

It was called Secret Crush. Many people searched for it, especially in countries where it never launched. This guide explains what it was, where it stands, and the alternatives available now if you want to find out whether a crush is mutual.

What was Facebook Secret Crush?

Secret Crush was part of Facebook Dating. Meta announced it at its F8 conference in 2019 and launched it with Facebook Dating in the US on 5 September 2019, along with 19 other countries, with Europe planned for 2020.

It worked like this:

  • you could choose up to nine of your Facebook friends or Instagram followers as crushes,
  • if one of them was also using Secret Crush and added you, it was a match,
  • if not, nobody was notified.

It was a simple, appealing idea: double-blind matching for people who already know each other.

Why many people never got to use it

  • It lived inside Facebook Dating. You needed a Dating profile, and your crush needed one too. Most people’s crushes weren’t using Facebook Dating.
  • It wasn’t everywhere. Facebook Dating’s availability has varied by country, and India was not in the 2019 launch list.
  • It was limited to Facebook and Instagram connections. People you knew only by phone number or from class weren’t included unless they were connected on those apps.

Is Secret Crush still available?

Facebook Dating still exists in some countries. In September 2025, Meta announced new features for it, including an AI dating assistant and “Meet Cute”, which sends weekly surprise matches, rolling out in the US and Canada. That announcement didn’t mention Secret Crush.

Features change, and availability differs by country, so the only reliable way to check is to open Facebook Dating in your own app, if it’s available where you live.

Alternatives for finding out if a crush is mutual

1. Coy: double-blind matching by phone number or email

Coy is built around the same core idea as Secret Crush, without needing a dating profile or a particular social network.

  • Add up to 3 people free, by phone number, email or both.
  • They get an anonymous heads-up that someone who has their number added them, never who. This is the main difference from Secret Crush: your crush doesn’t need to already be on the app, because the heads-up gives them the chance to join.
  • If they add you too, you both find out at the same moment, with a button to say hi on WhatsApp or email.
  • If they don’t, nothing happens and nobody ever knows.
  • Works with numbers from any country. It launched in India, starting with college campuses.

Messages are capped (at most one a week, three ever, never at night) and anyone can opt out for good. See how Coy works and is Coy safe?

2. Campus matching events

Some universities have matching traditions that run once a year. Marriage Pact, founded at Stanford in 2017, asks students a values-based questionnaire and pairs each person with a “backup spouse”; in its first year 58% of Stanford students signed up, and by late 2025 it ran on more than a hundred campuses. Datamatch, run by Harvard students, matches people around Valentine’s Day; in 2018 about 9,000 students at four colleges filled it in.

These are fun, but they match you based on a questionnaire, not on a specific person you already like. They’re closer to a campus-wide game than a way to ask “do they like me?”

3. Dating apps

Tinder, Bumble, Hinge and others are built for meeting new people. You might find your crush there, but swiping on someone you know is a different experience from a private, double-blind question, and many people you know won’t be on them.

4. Asking directly

The oldest alternative still works. It’s higher risk, but it’s honest and quick. Our guide on how to tell your crush you like them has scripts that leave room for any answer.

How they compare

Secret Crush Coy Campus matching Dating apps
Who you can pick Facebook friends, Instagram followers Anyone whose phone number or email you have Nobody specific; you get matched Whoever is on the app
Crush needs to be on the app already Yes, with a Dating profile No, they get an anonymous heads-up They need to take part that year Yes
What happens if it isn’t mutual Nothing Nothing Not applicable Not applicable
Availability Some countries, inside Facebook Dating Any country’s mobile numbers Participating campuses Most countries
Cost Free First 3 free; extra slots from ₹49 Free Free with paid tiers

What to watch out for in “secret crush” apps

Searching for a secret crush app will turn up all sorts of results. Before you trust one, check:

  • Does it send fake messages? In 2024 the US Federal Trade Commission took action against the anonymous messaging app NGL, which it said sent fake computer-generated messages and charged for “hints” about senders that weren’t real names. NGL agreed to pay $5 million and was banned from offering the app to under-18s.
  • Does it sell hints? Any app that charges to reveal clues is undermining the anonymity it promises.
  • Is it for adults? Crush apps aimed at teenagers carry real risks.
  • Can people opt out easily? Being messaged about a crush should never feel like harassment.

Our comparison of anonymous crush apps goes into these risks in more detail.

Frequently asked questions

What was Facebook Secret Crush?

A Facebook Dating feature launched in 2019 that let you pick up to nine Facebook friends or Instagram followers. If someone you picked also picked you, it was a match. Otherwise, nobody was told.

Is Facebook Secret Crush available in India?

India wasn’t in the 2019 launch list for Facebook Dating, and availability varies by country. Check Facebook Dating in your own app to see what’s available where you live.

Is there an app like Secret Crush that works with phone numbers?

Yes. Coy lets you add crushes by phone number or email. If they add you too, you both find out at the same moment; if not, nobody ever knows.

Does my crush need to have the app?

On Coy, no. They get an anonymous heads-up and can join if they want to. On Secret Crush, they needed a Facebook Dating profile.

Are secret crush apps safe?

Some are, some aren’t. Look for apps that don’t send fake messages, don’t sell hints, are for adults only and let people opt out easily.

Sources

  • Meta. Facebook Dating launch, including Secret Crush (5 Sept 2019). about.fb.com
  • Meta. Facebook Dating adds features to address swipe fatigue (Sept 2025). about.fb.com
  • Marriage Pact. Wikipedia
  • Datamatch 2018 numbers. The Harvard Crimson
  • US Federal Trade Commission (July 2024). Order against NGL Labs. ftc.gov

Someone you know might already have added you

Add up to 3 crushes by phone number or email. If they add you too, you both find out at the same moment. If they don’t, nothing happens and nobody ever knows.

Add your crushesHow Coy works

Free for your first 3 crushes. 18+ only.