Crush on someone in a relationship? What to do (and what not to)

Falling for someone who’s already taken is painful and common. How to handle the feelings, protect yourself and them, and when it’s time to let go.

By The Coy team5 minute read

On this page
  1. First: having the feeling isn’t wrong
  2. Why taken people can feel extra attractive
  3. What not to do
  4. What to do instead
  5. What if they break up?
  6. What if they flirt with you anyway?
  7. When it’s more than a crush
  8. Frequently asked questions

You didn’t plan it. They’re kind, funny, easy to talk to, and somewhere along the way you fell for them. There’s just one problem: they’re with someone else.

Having a crush on someone who’s taken is one of the most common and least talked-about kinds of heartache. This guide covers what’s going on, what to do with the feelings, and how to look after yourself.

First: having the feeling isn’t wrong

Crushes aren’t chosen. They grow out of time spent together, shared jokes and closeness. If you’ve spent a lot of time with someone, liking them is completely understandable, whether or not they’re available.

What matters is what you do with the feeling.

Why taken people can feel extra attractive

Part of it is simple: people in relationships are often relaxed, warm and secure, which is attractive. Part of it is safety: a crush on someone unavailable can feel low-risk, because nothing is expected to happen.

And part of it is uncertainty. Research suggests that not knowing how someone feels about you can make you think about them more. A crush on someone taken is full of “what ifs”, and “what ifs” keep a crush running.

What not to do

Don’t try to break them up

Hinting that their partner isn’t good enough, creating situations to get them alone, or positioning yourself as the “better option” can hurt three people, including you.

Don’t confess hoping they’ll leave

Telling someone in a relationship that you like them puts them in a very difficult position. If they’re happy, it creates awkwardness. If they’re not, it puts you in the middle of something that isn’t yours to fix.

Don’t become the emotional stand-in

If they come to you every time their relationship is struggling, and you stay hoping they’ll choose you, you can end up giving a lot and getting very little back.

Don’t keep it alive through constant contact

Late-night chats, daily messages, being the first person they share things with. It feels close, but it feeds a feeling that can’t go anywhere right now.

What to do instead

1. Name it to yourself

“I like them, and they’re not available.” Saying it plainly makes it easier to make clear choices.

2. Create some distance

You don’t have to cut them off, especially if they’re a friend or colleague. But reduce one-on-one time, late-night conversations and the small rituals that feel romantic. Repeated contact keeps feelings strong; less contact lets them fade.

3. Tell someone you trust

A friend outside the situation can help you keep perspective, and it relieves the pressure of carrying it alone. Choose someone discreet.

4. Look at the whole picture

Crushes thrive on an idealised version of a person. Research on breakups found that thinking about someone’s less appealing qualities reduced feelings of love, although it lowered mood in the moment. You don’t need to turn them into a villain, just let them be a real person.

5. Invest in your own life

New people, new plans, things you enjoy. A crush on someone unavailable can quietly stop you from noticing people who are available.

Our guide to getting over a crush has more detailed, research-backed steps.

What if they break up?

Relationships end, and sometimes the person you liked becomes available. If that happens:

  • Give them time. Someone fresh out of a relationship is often not ready for a new one.
  • Don’t swoop in. Being a good friend through a breakup is kind; being a hopeful one waiting for your chance can feel like pressure.
  • Check your own feelings. Do you still like them, or did the crush fade while you were moving on?

When the time feels right, you can find out privately whether it’s mutual. On Coy, you add them by phone number or email. If they add you too, you both find out at the same moment. If they don’t, nothing happens and nobody ever knows.

What if they flirt with you anyway?

If someone in a relationship flirts with you, it’s worth being cautious. They may be unhappy, they may enjoy attention, or they may simply be flirty by nature. Either way, it’s their relationship to sort out, not yours. Being the person someone cheats with rarely ends well for the third person.

When it’s more than a crush

If your feelings are taking over your days, affecting your sleep or work, or you’re feeling hopeless, please talk to someone you trust or a counsellor. In India, Tele-MANAS is a free government mental health helpline, available 24x7 at 14416 or 1800-891-4416.

Frequently asked questions

Is it wrong to have a crush on someone in a relationship?

No. Feelings aren’t chosen. What matters is respecting their relationship and looking after yourself.

Should I tell someone in a relationship that I like them?

Usually not. It puts them in a difficult position and rarely helps you move on.

How do I stop liking someone who’s taken?

Create some distance, reduce one-on-one contact, talk to someone you trust, see them realistically and invest in your own life.

What if they’re unhappy in their relationship?

That’s for them to sort out. Being a friend is fine; waiting to be their next relationship tends to keep you stuck.

What if they become single?

Give them time to recover, check whether you still feel the same, and find out gently or privately when it feels right.

Sources

  • Whitchurch, E. R., Wilson, T. D., & Gilbert, D. T. (2011). Uncertainty can increase romantic attraction. APS summary
  • Langeslag, S. J. E., & Sanchez, M. E. (2018). Down-regulation of love feelings after a romantic break-up. BPS Research Digest
  • Mere exposure and propinquity. Overview
  • Tele-MANAS. Free Press Journal

Someone you know might already have added you

Add up to 3 crushes by phone number or email. If they add you too, you both find out at the same moment. If they don’t, nothing happens and nobody ever knows.

Add your crushesHow Coy works

Free for your first 3 crushes. 18+ only.