Attachment styles and crushes: why you like people the way you do
Anxious, avoidant or secure? What attachment research says about how people experience crushes, why some of us chase and others run, and how to feel steadier.
On this page
Some people with a crush text constantly, check their phone every two minutes and feel crushed by a slow reply. Others feel the same attraction and immediately want to run the other way, especially if the person seems to like them back. A lucky few just enjoy it.
Psychologists have a framework that helps explain these differences: attachment styles. Here’s what it is, what the research found, and how it can help you understand your own crushes.
Where attachment theory comes from
Attachment theory began with research on how babies bond with their caregivers. Psychologist Mary Ainsworth described different patterns: some infants were secure, others anxious or avoidant.
In 1987, Cindy Hazan and Phillip Shaver asked a question nobody had properly tested: do adults show similar patterns in romantic love? They ran a “love quiz” in a newspaper, asking readers to pick the description that best fit their romantic feelings. About 56% described themselves as secure, 24% as avoidant and 20% as anxious-ambivalent, proportions close to those seen in infants.
Hazan and Shaver were careful about one point: these patterns are tendencies, not destiny. Later relationships can change how people attach.
The three styles, and how they show up in crushes
Secure
In general: comfortable with closeness, not too worried about being abandoned.
With a crush: you feel the excitement, but it doesn’t take over your life. You can wait for a reply without spiralling, and if it’s not mutual, it hurts but you recover.
Anxious (anxious-ambivalent)
In general: wanting closeness very much, and worrying a lot that others don’t feel the same.
With a crush: constant checking, overanalysing messages, mood swings tied to their attention, difficulty letting go even after a no. Mixed signals feel unbearable. If this is you, our guides to stopping overthinking and mixed signals are worth a read.
Avoidant
In general: uncomfortable with too much closeness or depending on others.
With a crush: you might like people who are unavailable or distant, feel attracted at a safe distance, and then lose interest or feel trapped when someone likes you back. We dig into that in why do I lose interest when my crush likes me back?
Why the styles clash so often
An anxious person and an avoidant person can get stuck in a loop: one reaches out more as the other pulls back, which makes the first reach out even more. From the inside, it looks like mixed signals. Uncertainty makes it worse: research has found that not knowing how someone feels increases how much you think about them, which feeds the anxious side of the loop.
How to use this without labelling yourself
Attachment styles are a useful lens, not a diagnosis. A few ways to use them well:
- Notice patterns, not single moments. One anxious week doesn’t make you “an anxious type”.
- Look at what triggers you. Slow replies? Someone getting close? That tells you where to focus.
- Build security in small ways. Keep your own routines, friendships and interests strong, so a crush is part of your life rather than all of it.
- Choose clarity over guessing. Anxious feelings shrink when uncertainty does.
- Talk about it. With friends, a counsellor, or eventually a partner. Saying “I get anxious when I don’t hear back” is surprisingly disarming.
Where Coy fits
Many anxious feelings around crushes come from not knowing, and many avoidant ones from the pressure of being the one to go first. Coy takes away both. You add someone privately. If they add you too, you both find out at the same moment, and nobody had to make the first move. If they don’t, nothing happens, and nobody ever knows. See how Coy works.
When to get support
If anxiety about relationships is affecting your sleep, work or wellbeing, or you keep repeating painful patterns, a counsellor can help. In India, Tele-MANAS is a free government mental health helpline, available 24x7 at 14416 or 1800-891-4416.
What a secure crush looks like
It can help to picture the goal. With a more secure approach to a crush:
- You enjoy their messages without needing them to feel okay.
- A slow reply is just a slow reply.
- You can say what you feel, or find out, without it feeling like life or death.
- If it isn’t mutual, it hurts, and then it fades.
- Your friends, work and hobbies stay part of your life.
Nobody feels like this all the time. But each time you choose clarity over guessing, and your own life over constant checking, you practise it.
A note on online quizzes
You’ll find plenty of “what’s your attachment style?” quizzes online. They can be a fun starting point, but they’re not a diagnosis, and the same person can show different patterns in different relationships. Use them as prompts for reflection, not as labels.
Frequently asked questions
What are the attachment styles?
The original adult research described three: secure, avoidant and anxious-ambivalent. Later work added more detail, but these three are the common starting point.
How common is each attachment style?
In Hazan and Shaver’s 1987 newspaper study, about 56% described themselves as secure, 24% as avoidant and 20% as anxious-ambivalent.
Can your attachment style change?
Yes. Researchers describe these patterns as tendencies, and later relationships and experiences can change them.
Why do I get so anxious about my crush?
If you tend toward anxious attachment, uncertainty about someone’s feelings can feel very threatening. Getting clarity and keeping a full life outside the crush both help.
Why do I only like people who are unavailable?
For people who tend toward avoidance, unavailable people can feel safe because closeness isn’t on the table. Noticing the pattern is the first step to changing it.
Sources
- Hazan, C., & Shaver, P. (1987). Romantic love conceptualized as an attachment process. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. Simply Psychology
- Whitchurch, E. R., Wilson, T. D., & Gilbert, D. T. (2011). Uncertainty can increase romantic attraction. APS summary
- Tele-MANAS. Free Press Journal